Home, Enguerran Avril

Case study · Criteo · 2011–2020

Criteo

Eight and a half years: banners for the biggest clients, then the templates and the tool that made them, then the first product clients used on their own.

Company
Criteo, advertising technology
Roles
Creative Designer, Senior Creative Designer, then Product Designer from 2014
Period
September 2011 – February 2020
Where
Paris, with teams in Europe, the US and APAC
Products
Campaign manager (first self-service module), Design Tool, demo page, Dynamic Video Ads, Facebook Active Elements
Tools
Photoshop, then Sketch; Figma at the very end

At a glance

The challenge

Criteo grew fast: banners for hundreds of accounts in many markets, designers in offices around the world, and clients who relied on Criteo’s teams to set up every campaign.

What I did

Designed banners for Criteo’s biggest clients in France. In Creative Services, transformed the Design Tool and its demo page, designed all of the company’s templates and gathered needs in five offices. Then designed the first self-service campaign manager.

The outcome

A Design Tool used by every Criteo designer; templates combined by Darwin into up to 3,000 banners for one placement; and the first module clients could use on their own.

Impact

  • ÷2time to generate the creative designs for Criteo’s retailers, with the Design Tool
  • ~100people trained, from New York to Tokyo
  • 50+internal users on the self-service campaign manager

How it was measured: user test sessions and feedback from users.

Campaigns Status: Goal: Date range:03/05/2018 - 04/03/2018
Sorts the campaigns below by this total.
On or off
Campaign
Goal
Daily budget
Imps
Clicks
CTR
CPC
Spend
Sales
Revenue
ROAS
Actions
Retargeting – Spring collectionActiveID 104882
Revenue
€400.00
4,395,211
31,206
0.71%
€0.36
€11,240.18
702
€64,890.30
577%
Retargeting – Cart abandonersLimited by budgetID 104117
Conversions
€250.00
1,950,000
17,940
0.92%
€0.42
€7,498.60
512
€41,203.80
549%
Prospecting – Similar buyersActiveID 113405
Visits
€220.00
7,364,242
24,302
0.33%
€0.24
€5,816.90
98
€6,410.20
110%
Retargeting – Product viewers, 30 daysActiveID 104563
Conversions
€180.00
1,779,487
13,880
0.78%
€0.35
€4,912.44
236
€18,940.00
386%
Retargeting – Past buyers, 90 daysActiveID 109230
Revenue
€90.00
1,011,594
6,980
0.69%
€0.37
€2,604.12
141
€14,120.60
542%
Retargeting – Newsletter clickersLimited by budgetID 110874
Conversions
€80.00
720,000
6,120
0.85%
€0.39
€2,398.10
89
€7,420.60
309%
Retargeting – App users (iOS & Android)Paused · since 03/21ID 107651
Conversions
€120.00
967,241
5,610
0.58%
€0.34
€1,906.55
71
€5,302.90
278%
Clearance – Last piecesPaused · since 03/20ID 111902
Conversions
€60.00
395,082
2,410
0.61%
€0.35
€846.20
33
€2,180.50
258%
Mother’s Day – Gift ideasLearning · day 5 of 7ID 118336
Revenue
€150.00
231,538
1,204
0.52%
€0.38
€462.30
19
€1,630.70
353%
Prospecting – Interior design fansLearning · day 4 of 7ID 118410
Visits
€100.00
490,323
1,520
0.31%
€0.19
€288.40
6
€410.00
142%
Spend is what your campaigns cost over the period. 1–10 of 14 campaigns
A reconstruction of the campaign manager in the style of the real product of 2016, with fictional data. It works: walk through the five steps, change the budget, launch the campaign. Then take the tour of its pain points, or show the specs.

Pain points, before and after

The changes play on the screen above, the problem first and then the fix. Pick one to see it again.

Act 1: Banners, 2011–2014

I started at Criteo as a designer, and I was the one working for its biggest clients in France.

I designed retargeting banners, the ads that show people the products they looked at on a retailer’s site: for European clients, among them Air France, Accor Hotels and 3 Suisses, then Booking.com, Fnac and La Redoute. As Creative Designer, then Senior Creative Designer, I looked after a portfolio of more than 300 accounts, with Sales, Account Management and the technical teams.

Presentation board of retargeting banners for Air France.
Air France
Presentation board of retargeting banners for Accor Hotels.
Accor Hotels
Presentation board of retargeting banners for 3 Suisses.
3 Suisses
Presentation board of retargeting banners for Eurosport.
Eurosport
Presentation board of retargeting banners for Galeries Lafayette.
Galeries Lafayette
Presentation board of retargeting banners for Cdiscount.
Cdiscount
Presentation board of retargeting banners for BNP Paribas.
BNP Paribas
Presentation board of retargeting banners for Boulanger.
Boulanger
Presentation board of retargeting banners for Chanel.
Chanel
Presentation boards of retargeting banners from those years.

Act 2: The Design Tool, 2014–2017

As Criteo grew fast, a central Creative Services team was created. I joined it, in charge of transforming the Design Tool, the internal tool every Criteo designer used to build banners.

I gathered the needs of designers around the world, created new layouts for new markets and verticals, and added many features to the tool, with continuous improvements driven by designers and by local needs. I also worked a lot on the demo page, which showed a banner in place, on a publisher’s page.

The new Design Tool halved the time it took to produce the creative designs for Criteo’s retailers, and brought their banners to market faster.

Another project: assigning the product feed’s data to each text field of a banner, and managing the discount coupons sent to customers. I designed it in Photoshop.

Boulanger

  • Boulanger banner as delivered, multiple layout
  • Boulanger banner as delivered, zoom layout
  • Boulanger banner as delivered, slideshow layout

Chanel

  • Chanel banner as delivered, multiple layout
  • Chanel banner as delivered, zoom layout
  • Chanel banner as delivered, mosaic layout
  • Chanel banner as delivered, slideshow layout

Accor Hotels

  • Accor Hotels banner as delivered, showcase layout
  • Accor Hotels banner as delivered, multiple layout
  • Accor Hotels banner as delivered, slideshow layout
  • Accor Hotels banner as delivered, classic layout

3 Suisses

  • 3 Suisses banner as delivered, multiple layout
  • 3 Suisses banner as delivered, mosaic layout
  • 3 Suisses banner as delivered, slideshow layout
  • 3 Suisses banner as delivered, classic layout
Not the original interface: a design tool drawn for this page around the real one’s features, with the logos and product images of real banners from those years. Pick a partner, a market and a template; click any part of the banner to edit it in the inspector; give each text field a column of the product feed; add a coupon; compare with the banner as delivered. Japan adds its legal mentions; Arabic turns the layout right to left. Demo puts the banner on a publisher’s page.
A whiteboard with hand-drawn banner sketches and printed layout sheets.
Sketches and printed layouts on the whiteboard.
A wall covered in printed banner iterations.
Iterations printed and pinned up.
A delivered set of Boulanger banners in several formats, open in a file viewer.
A delivered set of Boulanger banners in the shared archive.

On the road

From Paris, I went to the local teams in Munich, Barcelona, Boston, New York and Tokyo.

Read the detail: On the road

In each city I trained the designers on the Design Tool and gathered the needs of the local teams. On these trips I also gave talks, met clients and the top management of each country, and talked with the people who used our tools, to understand how they used them. I defined personas from it. What I brought back shaped the new layouts and the tool’s features.

In Barcelona sat the small and medium market team, for Criteo’s smallest clients, with a very particular and highly automated offer. I worked with them on automating their process, so they could answer requests as fast as possible.

Around a hundred people went through these trainings. Back in Paris, I created and ran Criteo’s creative product knowledge base, and the guidelines it held travelled through the same trainings. With the local teams, I ran workgroups that enriched the specifications, reviewed them with R&D, iterated on the first versions, then planned and ran the rollouts.

It was the beginning of product design, and that is how I started doing it.

Cities

Pick a city

 

Local time
–
From Paris
–

Munich

Germany

Local time
–
From Paris
684 km

Barcelona

Spain

Local time
–
From Paris
831 km

Boston

United States

Local time
–
From Paris
5,531 km

New York

United States

Local time
–
From Paris
5,837 km

Tokyo

Japan

Local time
–
From Paris
9,712 km

Why I went

  • Train the local teams on the Design Tool
  • Bring back their needs
  • Meet clients

Flown from Paris, one way22,595 km

The trips from Paris. Pick a city to see why I went, and what time it is there now.

What came back

The needs of each office went on the wall, then into themes, and from there into the layouts and the tool.

  • What we saw
  • What got in the way
  • What they asked for

Drag the notes, then sort them into themes.Sort the notes into themes.

  1. Japan

    • Japanese clients’ sites are long one-pagersTokyo
    • Legal mentions have to appear on the bannerTokyo
    • Keep a line for legal text in every layoutTokyo

    What we took from it

    Layouts that leave room for each market’s legal text.

  2. Right to left

    • We are opening the Arab countries
    • Every layout reads left to right
    • Arabic needs mirrored layouts

    What we took from it

    Layouts rebuilt so that they can be written right to left.

  3. Formats and sizes

    • New banner sizes
    • New formats, mobile included

    What we took from it

    New sizes and formats added to the layout offer.

  4. Animation

    • New types of animation
    • Flash and HTML must move the same way

    What we took from it

    A set of animations that every layout can use.

  5. Verticals

    • An offer for automotive
    • An offer for gambling
    • Travel and retail don’t sell the same way

    What we took from it

    A full offer of layouts, vertical by vertical.

  6. Banners at scale

    • More than 300 accounts, each with its own brand
    • Create banners more easily
    • Change them faster

    What we took from it

    Darwin: layouts combined into up to 3,000 banners for one placement.

Needs brought back from the offices, recreated as an affinity wall for this page and sorted into themes.

Darwin and the templates

The developers built Darwin, a technology that assembled banners easily, so that we could make a great many templates. I designed all of the company’s templates at the time.

Read the detail: Darwin and the templates

Those needs became a full offer of layouts, with offers by vertical: automotive, gambling and others. The layouts could be combined, up to 3,000 banners for one placement. A designer picked preselected templates and supplied colour assets only; the product feed was linked so that each field landed in the right place; a few settings did the rest. Darwin adapted the font sizes and the colours of each banner.

Darwin ran on Duplo, an infrastructure the developers had set up to assemble banners from containers, so that banners were quicker to create and to change. By then I had started doing product design, working with a product manager and the development team.

Criteo — Templates

The template file of the retargeting banners: one page per banner size with an artboard for each layout, built from named containers whose text layers carry the product-feed column they display, and a page of symbols.

  1. 300×250Classic · Multiple · Mosaic · Slideshow · Showcase · Zoom
  2. 728×90Classic · Multiple · Mosaic · Slideshow · Showcase · Zoom
  3. 160×600Classic · Multiple · Mosaic · Slideshow · Showcase · Zoom
  4. SymbolsContainer/Logo · Container/Image · Container/Title · Container/Price · Container/Cta · Container/Nav dots · Container/Nav numbers · Container/Arrow prev · Container/Badge · Container/Zoom tag · Container/Tag · Container/Legal

The template file of the retargeting banners: one page per banner size with an artboard for each layout, built from named containers whose text layers carry the product-feed column they display, and a page of symbols.

The templates as they lived in Sketch, recreated: every layout, in each banner size, built from named containers. Pick a size, select a layer, read its properties.

Boulanger

  • Boulanger banner as delivered, multiple layout
  • Boulanger banner as delivered, zoom layout
  • Boulanger banner as delivered, slideshow layout

Chanel

  • Chanel banner as delivered, multiple layout
  • Chanel banner as delivered, zoom layout
  • Chanel banner as delivered, mosaic layout
  • Chanel banner as delivered, slideshow layout

Accor Hotels

  • Accor Hotels banner as delivered, showcase layout
  • Accor Hotels banner as delivered, multiple layout
  • Accor Hotels banner as delivered, slideshow layout
  • Accor Hotels banner as delivered, classic layout

3 Suisses

  • 3 Suisses banner as delivered, multiple layout
  • 3 Suisses banner as delivered, mosaic layout
  • 3 Suisses banner as delivered, slideshow layout
  • 3 Suisses banner as delivered, classic layout
Darwin, recreated. Switch templates, colour assets and settings on and off and watch the count: in this recreation, 6 templates × 5 colour sets × 4 typographies × 5 animations × 5 calls to action make 3,000 banners for one placement. Hover a banner to play its animation, or show the Duplo containers it is assembled from.

New formats

The same years brought mobile and touch formats. I designed them as templates, with the gestures that drive them.

I also designed for Dynamic Video Ads and Facebook Active Elements.

A phone showing a news page with a Uniqlo banner, next to the banner’s states: intro, products, selection, action, details, next product.
A 728×90 rich-media leaderboard on a phone: tap a product to select it, tap again to shop, swipe up for details or the next product.
Six states of a 300×250 touch banner with hand gestures.
A 300×250 touch banner: swipe up or down for other products, swipe left for details or to dismiss, double tap to zoom on the image.
A sheet of mobile touch templates with their variants.
Mobile touch templates: one layout and its variants.
Jet2holidays banners in several layouts.
Layouts for Jet2holidays: neutral, multiple, mosaic, slideshow and showcase.
Gesture rules for banners on phones and tablets, with hand drawings.
Gesture rules for phone and tablet banners.

Act 3: The campaign manager, 2017–2020

In the new Product Design team, I designed Criteo’s first self-service module, a campaign manager: a campaign dashboard and campaign creation, the first module clients could use directly.

Read the detail: The campaign manager, 2017–2020

Until then, Criteo’s teams set up campaigns for clients. Putting the tool in clients’ hands was a major change for the business. The launch came in stages: internal teams first, then clients in beta. We tested it over many sessions with everyone involved in taking a campaign live, from tag implementation to data analysis: more than 30 sessions, most of them in Paris and the rest by video with teams in other countries. I wrote the specs, built the prototypes, improved the process around them, and worked on the rollout with teams in the US, APAC and Europe. I designed it with Criteo’s design system, and contributed to the system as well.

The figure at the top of this page rebuilds the campaign manager in its style, with fictional data; its specs overlay shows how I documented a screen for developers.

Before
Client
Criteo teams set up the campaign
Campaign
After
Client
Campaign manager: campaign dashboard and creation, used by the client
Campaign
What the module changed.

In February 2020 I joined iBanFirst as Senior Product Designer.

Decisions that shaped it

Three choices made the difference.

  1. Go to the offices.

    Why
    Designers in Munich, Barcelona, Boston, New York and Tokyo had needs a central team could not guess: legal mentions in Japan, right-to-left layouts, new formats.
    What it led to
    New layouts, offers by vertical, features in the Design Tool, and personas.
  2. Templates, not one-off banners.

    Why
    Hundreds of accounts in many markets: banners had to be quicker to create and to change.
    What it led to
    All of the company’s templates, combined by Darwin into up to 3,000 banners for one placement.
  3. Put the tool in the clients’ hands.

    Why
    Until then, Criteo’s teams set up every campaign for its clients.
    What it led to
    Criteo’s first self-service module, a campaign manager opened first to internal teams, then to a few clients in beta, and rolled out with teams in the US, APAC and Europe.